Hall of Fame inductions are usually designed to stage an uneasy truce, gathering estranged players around a microphone to pretend the bad blood never happened. When Joy Division and New Order entered the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame together on November 14 at the Peacock Theater in Los Angeles, there was no pretense of a reunion. Bassist Peter Hook was the sole representative on hand to collect the statuette, flanked not by his estranged colleagues from Manchester, but by a substitute band drawn from alternative rock and modern pop.
Nine Inch Nails frontman Trent Reznor introduced both groups, arguing that their combined reach over the past half century altered the shape of alternative music permanently. Reznor walked the audience through their journey from the bleak, icy post-punk of late-seventies Manchester to the club-ready electronic rock that defined their second act. He credited that shift with showing him how to experiment without fear in his own work, pointing out that everyone from U2 and Radiohead to the Cure, the Killers, Nirvana, and Deche Mode owes a debt to what the Manchester musicians built.
When it came time to play, Hook put together an unexpected ensemble. He brought out Chino Moreno and the rest of Deftones, along with Chvrches vocalist Lauren Mayberry, to run through a two-song set representing both eras. The group started with Joy Division's 1980 single Love Will Tear Us Apart before sliding into New Order's 1986 dance track Bizarre Love Triangle. Hook's high-register basslines grounded the performance, balanced between Moreno's heavier vocal approach and Mayberry's synthpop background.
Taking the podium alone, Hook acknowledged the empty space around him right away, remarking that while he stood by himself, he was not alone. He dedicated the honor to the fans who spent years campaigning to get both groups onto the ballot. Looking back over five decades of making records, he described the experience as a wild run full of joy, anger, and heartbreak, adding that he was grateful to still be standing and thanking his guest bandmates for making an old man happy.
The induction officially recognized five people: Hook, singer Bernard Sumner, drummer Stephen Morris, keyboardist Gillian Gilbert, and the late Ian Curtis. Following the death of Curtis in 1980, the three surviving members regrouped with Gilbert to create New Order, pioneering electronic pop records that kept them together for decades. That run fractured when Hook walked away in 2007. When the others reformed without him in 2011, it triggered years of bitter litigation over royalties and the right to use the band name. A legal settlement was finally reached in 2017, yet the personal rift between Hook and his former collaborators has never closed.
Speaking with reporters after the ceremony, Hook made it clear that time has not softened his stance. He confirmed that he has no intention of forgiving the other members for what the protracted dispute did to him and his family. Still, he kept things light when asked what it might take to bring everyone back to the same stage, joking that if someone handed him an Oasis-sized check for two hundred million pounds, he might just change his mind.





