Saturday night at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame saw Peter Hook standing entirely by himself to collect the honours for Joy Division and New Order. It made for an unmistakable image. More than four decades after turning post-punk into a fresh blueprint for club music, Manchester's defining crossover act entered the institution represented by a solitary founder. Frontman Bernard Sumner chose not to attend, while drummer Stephen Morris and keyboard player Gillian Gilbert stayed away due to health issues, with Gilbert currently undergoing treatment for cancer. For anyone wondering whether the joint induction on November 14 might serve as an olive branch, Hook quickly dispelled the thought.

Rather than letting the absence turn the evening into a wake, Hook handled the performance duties with outside help. He took the stage to run through Joy Division's Love Will Tear Us Apart and New Order's Bizarre Love Triangle, recruiting Deftones and Chvrches to back him up. At the podium, he chose to set aside the decades of acrimony, at least while the cameras were rolling for his official acceptance. Addressing the room, he acknowledged that while he was unaccompanied at the microphone, he did not feel isolated. Instead, he handed the achievement straight to the supporters who campaigned and voted for the bands to be recognised. Looking back on half a century in music, Hook spoke of a wild run defined in equal measure by joy, anger, and heartbreak, reminding the crowd that while personalities inevitably clash, the songs and the listeners remain permanent.

Off the podium, the old grievances surfaced almost instantly. The fracture dates back to 2007, when Hook walked away from New Order after years of deepening friction over creative direction and personal relations. The group had famously pulled themselves together from the wreckage of Joy Division following the suicide of singer Ian Curtis in 1980, creating an entirely new template for modern alternative music in the process. When Hook walked, the fallout spilled straight into the legal system. New Order continued touring and releasing material without their signature bassist, while Hook launched his own group, The Light, to take the vintage catalogues back on the road. An eight-year courtroom fight followed, costing Hook years of earnings and hardening into an open feud with no end in sight.

The financial and ethical complaints have kept those wounds fresh. Hook has previously recounted how royalty splits left him collecting just a single penny for every pound generated by the group, an arrangement he characterised as deep treachery given his foundational role in writing and recording their catalogue. He has also repeatedly argued that touring under the New Order banner without his involvement amounted to misleading the public. Asked directly on Saturday whether those injuries could ever be healed, Hook gave no ground, stating plainly that he would never forgive his former bandmates for the heavy toll the prolonged dispute took on him and his family.

There is, by Hook's own admission, only one absurd circumstance that could make him reconsider. Looking around an induction class that also celebrated Oasis, Phil Collins, Billy Idol, and Wu-Tang Clan, Hook pointed to the massive stadium money generated by the recent Live 25 comeback. He joked that an offer in the neighborhood of 200 million dollars might convince him to share a stage with Sumner once more. Short of that impossible payout, or an improbable personal apology from Sumner for nearly a decade of litigation, the door is shut tight. The ceremony put their music into the history books, but the musicians who made it remain entirely divided.